How to Find and Train Judges for Traditional Competitions

A traditional competition depends on more than a stage, a timetable, and a willing group of contestants. The quality of judging shapes the reputation of the eisteddfod, influences whether competitors return, and helps communities decide which skills and traditions they want to pass on. Finding suitable adjudicators therefore deserves the same care as arranging a venue, recruiting stewards, or securing funding.

Judges for folk singing, folk dancing, recitation, instrumental performance, and cerdd dant need a strong command of their discipline. They also need to understand the character of a local eisteddfod, where encouragement, fairness, Welsh cultural knowledge, and community participation are all important. Expertise alone does not guarantee good adjudication.

A reliable approach combines careful recruitment, clear expectations, practical preparation, and continuing support. Committees that build a small network of trained judges will find it easier to cover annual events, respond to new competition formats, and protect consistent standards from one generation to the next.

Define The Standard Before Recruiting

Begin by writing a short judging brief for every competition category. It should explain the age range, performance length, language requirements, required piece or subject, and the qualities the adjudicator should assess. A folk dance competition may focus on rhythm, formation, interpretation, and cultural accuracy, while a cerdd dant class may require attention to melody, penillion singing, phrasing, and the relationship between voice and harp.

This brief gives potential judges a realistic picture of the role. It also prevents a committee from choosing someone simply because they are well known locally. A respected performer may have valuable knowledge but little experience giving constructive feedback, managing a tight schedule, or judging children sensitively.

Agree the scoring principles before approaching candidates. Decide whether marks will be divided between technical skill, interpretation, presentation, originality, and adherence to the competition rules. The exact weighting can differ between disciplines, but competitors should receive the same information that judges receive. Transparent criteria make decisions easier to defend and help new adjudicators prepare effectively.

Build A Broad Recruitment Network

The strongest candidates are often found through several overlapping networks rather than a single list of prominent names. Contact local music and dance groups, Welsh-medium schools, cultural societies, colleges, choirs, harpists, folk clubs, former competitors, and regional arts organisations. Ask tutors and experienced performers to recommend people who combine subject knowledge with patience and sound judgement.

Former competitors can become excellent judges when they have developed practical experience and understand the pressures of performance. They may need mentoring before taking sole responsibility, but their familiarity with current repertoire and youth participation can be particularly valuable. Retired teachers, conductors, choreographers, accompanists, and community arts workers may also offer deep knowledge that is not immediately visible through formal qualifications.

Use a written invitation that explains the date, location, approximate number of competitors, expected preparation, payment or expenses, and the format of the adjudication. Include whether the judge must speak Welsh, whether written comments are required, and whether the event expects a public adjudication. Clear information demonstrates respect for the candidate’s time and reduces late withdrawals.

Committees can also use established cultural networks and sector resources when widening their search. A useful starting point for understanding digital connections within the eisteddfod movement is the Steddfota background, which may help organisers identify relevant contacts, projects, or models of support without relying on informal recommendations alone.

Assess Experience And Suitability

A judge should be assessed against the needs of the specific competition, rather than selected through reputation alone. Ask candidates about their practical involvement in the discipline, experience teaching or mentoring, familiarity with relevant Welsh traditions, and understanding of the age group they will assess. Someone highly accomplished in adult concert performance may not be the right person for a beginner children’s class.

Request a short adjudication sample when appropriate. This could be a written critique of an anonymised performance, a discussion of a sample judging scenario, or a brief explanation of how they would separate technical accuracy from artistic interpretation. The purpose is not to create an examination. It is to see whether the candidate can make a balanced decision and communicate it in a way competitors can use.

Check for conflicts of interest before making an appointment. A judge should declare close family relationships, current pupils, regular ensemble members, or other connections that could affect confidence in the result. A conflict does not always make judging impossible, but the committee should agree in advance whether the person will withdraw from a class, disclose the connection, or be replaced.

Area To Assess Evidence To Seek Training Priority
Discipline knowledge Performance, teaching, conducting, choreography, or research experience Current rules and category-specific standards
Cultural understanding Knowledge of Welsh repertoire, forms, language, and local practice Context, terminology, and respectful feedback
Communication Clear spoken and written comments Concise adjudication and age-appropriate language
Fairness Ability to compare varied styles consistently Scoring calibration and conflict management
Reliability Previous work at organised events and good timekeeping Timetables, paperwork, and contingency procedures
Safeguarding awareness Experience working with children or vulnerable participants Reporting routes and professional boundaries

Create A Practical Training Pathway

Training should begin with an orientation rather than a large amount of theory. Send the rules, scoring sheet, timetable, venue plan, and expected adjudication format several weeks before the event. Highlight any recent changes, unusual competition requirements, pronunciation issues, or arrangements affecting disabled performers. Invite questions early so that uncertainty does not appear during the competition.

A useful development model has three stages. First, an aspiring judge observes an experienced adjudicator and records how marks and comments are formed. Second, the trainee completes a supervised practice session using recordings or a small class. Third, the trainee judges independently while a mentor reviews the decisions and feedback afterwards. This gradual route is especially helpful for young professionals and skilled performers who have never adjudicated publicly.

Calibration is central to consistency. Give several judges the same short set of performances and ask them to score each one independently. Compare the results, then discuss why marks differ. The aim is not to force identical scores; artistic work can reasonably produce different views. The exercise should reveal whether judges interpret the criteria in broadly similar ways and whether they can explain their decisions.

Include scenarios that test professional judgement. For example, ask how a judge would respond if a child forgot part of a piece, if an accompanist made an error, if a competitor used an unexpected traditional variation, or if a parent challenged a result. Role-play allows committees to examine tone, confidentiality, and consistency before an actual disagreement occurs.

Prepare Judges For The Event Day

Even an experienced adjudicator benefits from a detailed event briefing. Provide the running order, pronunciation guidance for names and place names, class rules, emergency contacts, break arrangements, and instructions for submitting marks. Explain whether comments will be delivered from the stage, privately to competitors, in writing, or through a combination of methods.

Time management deserves special attention. A judge who gives long feedback to the first few competitors may create delays that affect the whole day. Agree a reasonable length for public comments and identify which matters should be recorded privately. If the programme includes many children’s classes, schedule short breaks so concentration and patience remain strong.

The committee should also establish a clear process for corrections and complaints. Judges must know who can clarify a rule, amend a recording error, or respond to a formal challenge. They should not be expected to negotiate directly with an angry parent or competitor while trying to continue the class. A named event official can protect the judge and ensure that concerns are handled consistently.

Accessibility should form part of preparation. Ask whether the judge requires a suitable seat, accessible route, hearing support, large-print documents, or a quiet area for completing marks. Consider the needs of competitors too, particularly in dance and music classes where physical, sensory, or communication differences may affect how performance is presented. Fair judging means applying the published criteria thoughtfully rather than rewarding a single narrow style.

Support Ethical And Constructive Adjudication

Constructive feedback should identify what worked, explain what could improve, and offer a practical direction for future development. A comment such as “good performance” gives little help, while “your rhythm was secure; now work on clearer consonants in the final verse” is specific and encouraging. Judges should avoid sarcasm, comparisons that humiliate competitors, and comments about appearance or personality.

Children require particular care. Feedback should recognise effort and progress while remaining honest about the published standard. Judges should address the competitor respectfully, avoid discussing private information publicly, and remember that a result can feel significant even when the event is informal. When several age groups share a venue, the language and depth of feedback should be adapted to each group.

Cultural sensitivity is equally important. Traditional forms may have regional variations, evolving performance practices, and different relationships with language and pronunciation. A judge should distinguish between a genuine rule breach and a valid stylistic choice. Committees can support this by documenting the tradition behind each competition and ensuring that rules do not unintentionally exclude healthy local variation.

After the event, gather feedback from the adjudicator, competitors, teachers, and committee members. Review whether the scoring sheet was clear, whether the timetable allowed enough time, and whether comments were useful. This should be a development conversation rather than a fault-finding exercise. Good judges, like good organisers, improve when they receive precise information about what happened.

Strengthen The Local Judging Pool

A single annual appointment does little to secure the future of traditional competitions. Keep a confidential record of judges’ disciplines, language abilities, experience, availability, and training completed. Update it each year and note which candidates are ready for observation, supervised judging, or independent appointments. This turns recruitment into a continuing community resource.

Consider appointing an assistant adjudicator or shadow judge for larger events. The assistant can manage notes, observe the process, and learn how decisions are made without carrying full responsibility. In smaller competitions, a short pre-event workshop can bring several potential judges together to review rules and practise using the same marking framework.

Practical Steps For Committees

Investment in judges also strengthens the wider eisteddfod ecosystem. When adjudicators understand the cultural purpose of a competition, feedback becomes part of learning rather than a final verdict. Competitors gain confidence, teachers receive useful direction, and committees develop a reputation for fairness that attracts future participants.

Carry The Tradition Forward

Traditional competitions remain healthy when skilled people are given a clear route into leadership. By recruiting widely, defining standards, training patiently, and reviewing each event, local committees can build judging teams that are authoritative, kind, and consistent.

Use the next competition cycle to identify one experienced mentor, one developing adjudicator, and one area where the current process can be clearer. Share resources across neighbouring eisteddfodau, support Welsh cultural training, and make judging development part of ordinary event planning. Strong judges help ensure that folk singing, folk dancing, cerdd dant, and related traditions continue to be performed, understood, and valued by future generations.